Friday, 29 June 2012

Pickup Frequency Response Measurement. Humbucker, Single coil and Shuntbucker.


Well the shuntbucker has been in for a while now and I am still trying to get my head around how good it sounds. As it happened I did a pickup swap and quick setup for a PRS Tremonti SC (the cheap one) last week and was paid with the old pickups, which was more than I wanted. Anyway I now have a pair of ex PRS Korean generic humbuckers measuring about 10.1k DC resistance to play with.

I thought it would be the perfect test vehicle for a frequency response measurement comparing normal humbucker wiring, the normal shorting of the slug coil for single coil type response and the 47nF shuntbucker mod. First though I would need a stable and repeatable frequency measurement kit. It took a few swipes as you have to energise both the pickup coils with opposite magnetic polarity and it needed to work from low Hz to high kHz. Anyway to cut a long story short, I soon had a rig using a frequency generator, an OPA540 as the coil driver and an energiser coil. The output of the pickup was connected to a 100k resistive load and measured on an oscilloscope. This was a slight limitation as I would like to have measured at 500k but it’s the input impedance of the FET scope probe I used. To eliminate ambient noise the measurement was taken as an average of 100 consecutive measurements. The output in mV is plotted below. I have since reduced the drive amplitude as the output was higher than expected.

The blue plot is the normal humbucker. The red plot is with the slug coil shorted to ground which is normal practise for coil tapped pickups. In this configuration you acn see that the resonant peak has shifted to a higher frequency giving the expected single coil sound.  The green curve is the shuntbucker mod with a 47nF capacitor to ground across the slug coil. As this is directly injecting a magnetic field you won't see the inverse behaviour caused by fat strings producing a higher magnetic signature than say the thin top E string, which helps flatten all this out.


From this you can see that the 47nF worked as expected and has adopted the humbuckers low end frequency response. What is evident is that using a straight 47nF has produced some resonance with the coil which is why it appears to have a higher output compared with the humbucker configuration at 400Hz. You see the effect again at 800Hz as the kink in the otherwise smooth curve.  By adding a series resistance the resonance can be modified and a much cleaner transition from humbucker to single coil can be obtained. At the high end the shuntbucker follows pretty much the higher resonant peak of the normal single coil configuration. Hence a shuntbucker is like a single coil but with hairy balls.

 I think I will need to measure the spot frequency impedance of the humbucker and single coil configurations to work out the ideal shuntbucker capacitor series resistor. I could just try it out but I think the data will be useful. It could be I end up with two resistor/capacitor nets and possibly look at pulling the high frequency resonant peak about.

Monday, 11 June 2012

Humbucker coil tap with passive shunt, or Shuntbucker.

I have been fitting the pickups to my guitar build and they came with five wires. A shield wire and green ground wire combined. The coil tap connection red and white together and black for hot. It occurred to me whilst wiring it all in that simply shorting out the bottom coil to ground to coil tap whilst giving a good single coil sound, was a bit simplistic and short sighted. There has to be some use for the output of the now shorted coil other then dropping it to ground.

The easiest mod would be to short it to ground with a capacitor. This way I should get the brightness from the top coil but with some added bottom end and a small amount of hum-bucking from the bottom coil. If you plot the impedance (AC resistance) of say a 47nF (0.047uF) and 100nF capacitor you will get the following impedance values.


If  I presume that the _average_ impedance of each coil would be say 3k then you can see that with the 100nF capacitor (red plot) half of the output of the shunted coil will be lost via the capacitor at 500Hz.  Without some complicated measuring I can't be sure exactly what the impedance of the coil will be at a particular frequency. I do know how the capacitor works though and it had to be worth a go. I went with 47nF (blue plot) in the end and am very happy with the effect on the bridge humbucker. Below is the diagram showing the two coils from a humbucker and how the capacitor shunts the bottom coil.
Shuntbucker with frequency dependent shorting of unused coil.

It has a distinct change when tapped as you would expect but the pickup has a lot more balls, more P90 than strat sort of sound. For the bridge pickup this is ideal for me as I never found a use for a single coil bridge position. After trawling the net I did find that this is not a new idea, coil cut was a term I found amongs some others. Considering the simplicity of the modification, and the potential in using more complicated passive networks I am a little lost as to why the vast majority of sites will just short out the one coil and concentrate on additional phase and series parallel switching.

I think the major pickup manufacturers have also not actively brought to the fore this simple modification or even re-voiced there own pickups with a passive shunt so that when taped you get something better sounding. Combining a capacitor, inductor and resistor network across the lower coil could tailor curves into the pickup and tailor the response beyond wire gauge, turns and ad-hoc parasitics. It seems a vastly unexplored path, maybe it needs a name people can identify with, so maybe coining the term Shuntbucker would help it stick in the conscience.

EDIT:


I have found that as per the follow on article “Pickup Frequency Response Measurement.  Humbucker, Single coil and Shuntbucker” this really needs a series resistor with the capacitor to make this work. The issue is that the capacitor and coil inductance are too resonant and the transition results in the mid-range being swamped.  I have found that a 47nF and 3k3 resistor across the bottom coil works well for me.
 



HSG Mod front end design thoughts.


The HSG mod has a slightly different approach to the real valve gain setting and positioning of the voicing RC network attenuator compared to the original Soldano design.  Though not the final design this is a dialogue covering the thoughts I had in approaching the modification.  I will concentrate here primarily on the input stage and what I attempted to do to make more sense of the setting.  All values are from SPICE simulation using Microcap 9 evaluation edition from Spectrum software.  This is a free download and contains the 12AX7 / ECC83 models as standard from Duncan Munroe. 

The standard stage is set up pretty much from the off as a high gain amplifier. The valve is operated at a high gain and then droped with a passive resistor network with 1Meg as the gain pot This generates a lot of resistor noise and susceptibility to interference being a high impedance point then amplified by the rest of the preamp. The gain of the input valve is a combination of the anode resistor (220K) and the load resistor (1Meg pot + series resistor) over the cathode resistance.

 For the Soldano design below, with a 100mV input at the point marked VG1 the voltage at the V1A anode is 6.26V pk-pk or a gain of 62.37. However at point A at the input of the second stage and after the 1Meg series resistor the overall gain achieved is now 27.6 with the gain pot set to 100%. The quandary is that whilst 62.7 is pushing the valve fairly hard the overall gain achieved is modest, and I still have an issue with all that impedance and resistor noise on the input of the second stage.


In changing the GAIN pot to 100k in lieu of 1Meg it will reduce the resistor noise into the second stage but lower the gain of V1A. I can re-jig the gain by shorting out the attenuator R53. With a 100k anode resistor the valve gain is now 35.6 and due to effectively removing  R53 it remains at 35.6 at point A.  There is no blocking at the point between V1A and V1B.

All this doesn’t come without cost, the AC frequency response curves for both circuits are quite different.  However the low frequency  is recoverable by increasing C27 from 1uF to 4.7uF. The final curves are shown below. The red is the standard circuit with 100% gain at point A, the blue is modified including C27 = 4.7uF. 
The Soldano circuit also has a low frequency response that flattens and extends way below bottom E and into hand-on-string and bump noise and I didn’t see that helping either.  The modified circuit has a much wider frequency plot, so I can easily tweak the circuit to lose or re-voice this. The original circuit is pushed so especially at the high frequency end it is what it is.
 I worry that I have missed something here as I seem to find 1 meg-ohm as the default go-to value for the gain pot, and to me that doesn’t make sense.  

I should note that the dynamic range of the modified circuit is reduced because of the bias being unmoved but it will still take a 2.5V pk-pk signal before clipping the first stage which should be enough. If your humbucker is hotter than this then you are probably after clipping anyway. The important thing is that the modification can be tried without removing parts from the PCB and just placing parts or wires in parallel with the existing circuit. By reducing the gain of the valve I also hoped to remove some of the valve to valve dependency that other uses have reported. In the original design the high frequency end is dominated by the valve and not by circuit values.

Friday, 18 May 2012

Jet City DIY front panel.

The Jet City JCA20 comes with a "Marmite" front, you either love it or hate it. I am in the latter camp so decided to do something about it. At the same time I changed the knobs and the guaranteed-to-fail blue lamp. The panel was MDF and the cloth was from a previous project giving an old Peavey combo a face lift.

The whole surface had contact adhesive rolled on and when firmly stuck down staples were banged in at the rear to stop edges lifting. I wiped the back panel over with some blue fountain pen ink as a colour wash as you can see this from the back.  I did try some black chicken head knobs that I already but you just couldn't see where they were pointing.

The bottom edge of the new front had some router-love in the way of a round-over bit on both the front and the rear of the panel. The one on the back of the panel, though not visible makes a good gap for air-flow.




Monday, 14 May 2012

Grain Fill with Acrylic paint and Superglue (CY Glue)

The guitar build nearing the point where I need to think about the finish of the guitar, and having used Sepele, Black Walnut and Oak I felt it would be a shame not to use a transparent lacquer. However a test spray quickly showed how open grained all three are. The largest grain or pore voids by far are in the oak. I looked at all sorts of grain filler and followed a lot of posts suggesting cyanoacrylate (CY, crazy glue or superglue) which looked promising.

However in attempt to speed this up I decided to use a gold metallic acrylic paint to fill the large gaps and then CY glue to then grin fill the rest. I added about 30% volume of water to the acrylic paint and then rubbed it into the surface removing as much excess from the surface as possible. I then rubbed it down with 400 grit  and then sealed with superglue and left it to set. After initial sanding the finish is better than I expected. The gold has filled the largest voids and is _just_ visible when at the right angle. The end grain took more paint but here is an image of the top. I am very happy with this grain fill, the gold goes really well with the oak.

 I will add that I masked the black walnut and Sapele off so they just had the superglue grain fill. The superglue took three wipes and sanding to fill all the grain, but it's easy to work so it's just time spent more than anything else.

Below, poor picture but you can just make out threads of metalic gold acrylic grain fill in the oak. It looks slightly proud of the surface, but isn't.


Tuesday, 1 May 2012

Routing Out A Guitar Body.

I have started a new project based around a neck I got from Ebay. It was a 24 fret neck from an Aria M series in red. I have designed and routed out a body and have found the following useful.
1. Polish the base of the Router!
I used domestic spray furniture polish, and then buffed it dry with a cloth. I can't tell you how much of a difference this makes in controlling small movements of the router. I have since found that professionals use a spray on PTFE dry lubricant and I can see why. Not seen this tip anywhere else so maybe I am the only person who wasn't lubricating the base and everyone else already knows.
2. Never try for the BIG cut. 
I _gradually_ worked my way to the line. I had made a template and used a combination of cutters with the bearing at the top and bottom to get the body shape cut. The template had two layers of tape added to the edge at this stage which for the final pass (full length 50mm cutter with end bearing to do the 41mm body) I removed. The removal of the tape meant that the final pass was quick, without grab and left virtually no burn marks.
3. Keep EVERY off cut.
Practise for the large diameter bridge and tailpiece holes, finishing techniques, trial cutting, trial trim tools, you name it, keep all the offcuts you have.

I'll quickly run through the process that worked for me.

I managed to find some offcuts in a local timber supplier. A block of Sapele, a length of Black Walnut strip and a good chunk of Oak which had bounced on the planer and therefore had a defect area. All good low cost stuff. I cut and glued the wood to make a body-blank-sandwich. I made a Router-Planer from ideas on the Internet and trimmed it to 41mm

The first part was to draw a body shape. I used Paintshop to scale a PRS guitar body photo to real size using 150 pixels to an inch. I then used the distort tools to move the basic shape around and then used the curve draw tool to make new edges and lines. I could then print a portion of the overall design to A4 paper as full scale. By splitting the design into three sheets I could then print real-scale drawings taping together the sheets.  I included some red thin construction lines to aid alignment of the drawings. By the 8th design, iteration F it bore no resemblance to the PRS original and  I had a finished print which I glued down to 12mm thick MDF board. The MDF cuts well with a thin smooth cut Jig Saw blade and then I used a rasp (bottom of picture) and sandpaper to smooth the edges. Smooth lines here will pay dividends later and MDF is a lot softer than Oak.



The addition of drawn pickups and the neck cavity proved useful as well as the centre line being pre-printed. The final bridge will be a Les Paul type and not a Strat hardtail as in the original drawing.

The design was then transferred to the body blank and drawn on both sides. The blank had a centre line drawn on both sides. The distance from the base of the guitar from the edge ensured I was within a mm or so on both sides.



I then hand routed close to the edge with a 6mm dual cut router blade. This was SLOW work. You have to  go in 5-6mm depth steps but eventually you will remove wood and also end up at the depth limit of the cutter.


This is where accurately marking out on both sides with the template comes in. I then flipped the body over and began cutting again, though a bit further away from the line this time. As you can see below, I got daylight at last.


The template was then refitted and SCREWED to the top. This is where having the pickup marked acts as a sanity check when sticking a screw in. I started with a template cutter (bearing at the top) to cut an inch below the template. I then turned the body over and used a trim cutter (bearing at tip) to follow this cut and remove the rest of the material in a gentle manner.  As you can see below all the initial iterative cutting has left burn marks. For the final cut I removed the white tape and went with a full length cut trim cutter.



I have seen people using double sided tape to secure the template but I was glad I opted to use screws. I ended up moving the neck screw as I couldn't find a countersunk head screw and it got in the way of the router.


After the final cut very nearly all the burn marks were removed and the body had a good clean line and more importantly cleanly cut with no tear-out. Overall very pleased with progress so far.I'll update with more pictures as this progresses.




Sunday, 15 April 2012

Ebay Refret with EVO Gold and filler


I got a Profile Silhouette Strat copy off ebay. I paid £115 for a made in Japan Stat, about 30 years old in good condition advertised with not much fret wear. However on receipt it was evident that it had spent a good deal of time playing rhythm on the first five frets as several areas were utterly shot. I decided to keep the guitar but attempt my first refret. After some research I stumbled across EVO gold fretwire. It's _marginally_ more expensive than standard nickel silver, but much more wear resistant and has a nice gold hue to the metal. 


On removing the frets I noticed exactly how deep the slots are compared to the fret tang and how much more the neck moved in my hands. The frets are obviously part of the structure and rigidity of the neck. That and  and I am now working old fret slots. It can't be good.  My solution was to use a resin wood filler to pack the slot prior the instant before fitting the fret. I placed electrical tape either side of the fret slot, filled the slot quickly and then pulled the tape. This leaves a clean surface and a well filled slot. The wood filler cures very quickly so it was one slot at a time. The excess appears out of the side of the slot so it doubles up as the slot filling job at the same time. The truss rod plays a lesser part now as the fretboard in more structural than before.  Six months later there are no issues. I am sure someone will have an problem with filling the slot but in this instance it seems to have worked a treat.


 As for the Jescar EVO gold fretwire, it works easily, polishes beautifully and string bending is all too easy. Someone please explain why EVO Gold isn't used on everything now and why I have to spend a fortune with Gibson before they will fit it. It costs about £2 more than nickel.... As for the Profile copy, with some decent pickups now installed you would never put it down for a Fender seven times the cost. Below, banging in the frets and taping up for the next swipe of plastic wood filler. I hope it shows the gold in the fret, and when polished it's like glass.


Added photo below as this is in natural sunlight which correctly shows the subtle gold. The dot markers were also changed on the guitar. The standard dots fitted were white plastic so I bought a pack of MOP (mother of pearl) the same size. Removal of the old dot markers was simple. You just stick a soldering iron into the middle and gently rotate it round. The plastic melts first and the glue soon follows allowing for a very clean removal of the old dot marker.